Bull Cook and Authentic Historical Recipes and Practices
George Leonard Herter and Berthe Herter
1964 (ninth edition)
Thank you to Charlie S. for yet another fantastic recommendation and thank you to Alan Palmer at Blue Apron who lent me Volumes II and III. What would I do without the two of you?
George Herter owned a sporting goods store and catalogue business from the 1950’s to the 1970’s. He was a gun and rifle enthusiast and had his own line that he marketed through the catalogues. This cookbook shows that he was also an avid history buff, opinionated eater and all-around crank. It is a cooking tool, survival manual, travelogue, cultural thesis, and restaurant guide all rolled into one giant, crotchety treatise. And I have come to envision Herter himself as part George W. Bush, part Archie Bunker and part Unabomber. Here are some of my favorite quotes, although the list is far from exhaustive:
“Hollywood, thank goodness, is dead. Television has at least done incalculable good in destroying this evil group. Hollywood created an era where prostitutes were made national heroines simply because they bedded well with some studio owners.”
“Sauerbraten was invented by Charlemagne.”
“This recipe has done more good I believe than any other recipe in the world.” (regarding a recipe called Church Builder Chicken which is comprised of chicken, bacon, canned lima beans, canned corn and canned tomatoes)
“Chicken Kiev is served very well at the Cafe Exceptionale in Minneapolis, Minnesota. This is the only restaurant in North America that does serve it well.”
“Esoffier was one of the world’s good cooks.” (damning with faint praise anyone?)
“Seattle’s restaurants, with the exception of a very few sea food restaurants, are nothing at all to brag about. Most of them sell atmosphere, not food and at very high prices.”
“Never underestimate the Chinese People. The Koreans and Japanese are also pure Chinese.”
“This is the most fabulous recipe for preparing spaghetti that has ever been devised and is one of the few really original recipes of the past 100 years.” (It is spaghetti with Roquefort)
“Mayonnaise cannot be bought in grocery stores.”
When Herter makes statements like these it’s hard to imagine truthfulness or accuracy in his culinary research, but then again he clearly went to great trouble. Who knows if Chicken Kiev was invented by a Frenchman named Appert? I’m too lazy to verify.
The back portion of Volume I is what I like to call the “lifestyle” section: How to Make Soap; The Indian Method of Quitting Smoking; How to Dress a Deer; In case of a Hydrogen Bomb Attack You Must Know The Ways of Wilderness Survival. Now you see why this book was self-published (nine times apparently).
Alan did point out though, and I totally agree, that the traditional recipes he gives are very well written and accurate. I chose the broiled steak because Herter dedicates four entire paragraphs to this preparation and therefore it deserves respect. No measurements are given, just directions. Melt enough butter to cover the bottom of a pan and while warm but not hot, soak up both sides of the steak in the butter for 10-15 minutes. Then salt and pepper the steak and broil at 500 degrees, basting with the pan juices. Herter cooks his steak for 30-40 minutes but in this house we would rather eat shoes than well-done meat. After the steak is cooked, lift it with tongs “never a fork”, spread it with more butter and let it rest. Simple directions but very specific and I have to say that I have never, ever been able to achieve the nice char and crust on a steak the way I did with Herter’s method. It was spectacular.

I made Potatoes Madrid because Herter calls it “the finest of eating”. Take three heaping teaspoons of butter and melt in a frying pan, add three good sized shallots and fry until barely beginning to brown. Boil three large potatoes (I used 6 smaller, buttercream potatoes) then mash. He doesn’t specify so I did not remove the skins. Add two teaspoons butter, two teaspoons of cream and the browned shallots. Once again, simple but spectacular.


p.s. That’s plated with some yummy organic purple kale that I sauteed with artisanal bacon and garlic. Herter would probably shoot me for ruining his perfectly good food with my fancy-pantsy vegetables.